What is the Best Type of Roof Shingles?

New Asphalt Roof Shingles With Installation Tools Still on Top

Finding Your Ideal Roofing Material

When it comes to choosing the material that will largely determine whether or not your home is safe during the next few decades of thunderstorms, it pays to take your time. Roofing materials vary in cost, energy-efficiency, durability, and (of course) longevity. Homeowners need to weigh all of these factors as they consider their next roof replacement.

Today, we’ll be focusing mostly on the most popular solution on the residential market: asphalt roof shingles. By the end of this article, you should have a firm grasp of the pros and cons of shingle roofing, and whether or not it could be right for your home. Let’s dive in!

What’s the Best Roof for a House?

The best roofing solution for your home is one that fits within your budget while providing the greatest value towards your functional goals. Of course, that does require you (and your family) to decide what matters most. Your priorities could be any of the following:

  • Durability
  • Longevity
  • Affordability
  • Customizability
  • Convenience (Low-Maintenance)
  • Home Value Enhancement

There’s more to residential roofing than weather protection, yet there’s little value in a roof that can’t hold its own in a severe thunderstorm. The best systems are those that provide the most cost-effective, long-term functionality. We’ll get into some examples later.


What Type of Roof is Cheapest?

In general, your typical asphalt roof shingles offer the most affordable roofing options on the market. Base level shingle installation typically runs between $4500 and $9000, according to HomeAdvisor. If you wish to upgrade to a more resilient shingle (such as the architectural or impact-resistant varieties), expect a serious premium.

Take your installation estimate and divide it by the typical 15 to 20 year lifetime of asphalt roof shingles. While it doesn’t include potential repair costs, this creates a workable baseline for our upcoming comparisons.


What is the Most Durable Roofing Material?

Barring slate roofs (which are far out of our comparison price range), metal systems offer the strongest durability available on the residential market. Most metal roofs will last two and a half to three times longer than the maximum lifetime of asphalt roof shingles. In other words, expect 50 to 60 years of powerful weather protection (even against hail). If you’re the type of homeowner that enjoys the security of stronger siding, gate installation, and other protective home features, metal may be ideal for you!

Is a Metal Roof More Expensive Than a Shingle Roof?

If we take Roofing Calculator’s estimate for the average cost of a metal roof, we can expect the low end to fall at $14,500. That twice the price of asphalt roof shingles. For premium metal roofing systems (in this case, an aluminum standing seam installation), that amount rises to almost $20,000. That’s a remarkably higher price bracket.

Asphalt Roof Shingles Pros and Cons

There’s a reason why so many homeowners in the United States rely on asphalt shingles for their roofing needs. Their incredible affordability, prevalence, and style-diversity makes them a very convenient solution for many. Homeowners that don’t regularly struggle with extreme weather are especially fond of shingles.

However, shingles only provide fair protection against more serious weather phenomena (namely heavy wind and hail). This makes early replacement much more likely in the event of a damaging storm. They also feature a shorter max lifetime than most other forms of roofing.

Asphalt Shingle Pros & Cons

  • Pro: Very Affordable
  • Pro: Easily Accessible (material sourcing & installation)
  • Pro: Wide Variety of Styles, Quality Levels, and Enhancements
  • Con: Vulnerable Against Severe Weather
  • Con: Shorter Average Lifetime
  • Con: No Miscellaneous Energy Benefits or Tax Incentives


Asphalt Roof Shingles Cost

Let’s get down to the question that most homeowners are concerned with: “How much do asphalt shingles cost?” As we mentioned above, shingles generally run between $4500 and $9000. That includes installation, though that range may not include tearoff for the old roof.

Comparing Solutions

Asphalt Roof Shingles Comparison

Asphalt shingles are clearly more affordable than metal roofs. However, we already know that the cost of metal roofing is spread out over a much longer lifespan than basic shingles: 60 years vs 20. Metal roofs also provide substantially stronger weather protection than asphalt systems. Finally, metal roofing provides energy saving benefits for homeowners by reflecting a much higher percentage of light (subsequently reducing heat absorption).

Asphalt Roof Shingles vs Metal

  • Cost: Asphalt shingles are much cheaper.
  • Durability: Metal roofers absorb trauma better, requiring far fewer repairs.
  • Longevity: Metal roofs last 2.5 to 3 times longer than asphalt shingles.
  • Energy-Efficiency: Metal roofs provide notable heating and cooling cost reduction.
  • Convenience: Asphalt shingles are easier to install, though metal roofing is easier to maintain.

Both options offer fairly cost-effective protection, though metal roofing wins out in the long run. Ultimately, your budget will determine which option works best for your home.

A Roofer Tests the Slope of a New System

Get Your Roof Installation Estimate!

Looking for estimates on your next roof replacement? Let our experienced team at Covenant Roofing provide you with a quote on your next metal roof or asphalt roof shingles in Oklahoma City, OK! We’ll be thrilled to answer any questions you may have about the installation process. Simply call us at 405-720-6200 to learn more.